Research Descriptions of M.E.

           

          Wallis (1957)

           

          A study of the earliest recorded outbreak of epidemic M.E. in the UK appeared in the Thesis of Dr. Andrew Wallis, a Scottish physician, in 1957. It discusses an epidemic in Cumberland in Northern England in 1955. His definition of the chronic disease included the following features:

          1. A systemic illness with relatively low fever or subnormal temperature.
          2. Marked muscle fatigability.
          3. Mental changes with impairment of memory, mood, sleep disorders, depression.
          4. Involvement of the autonomic nervous system resulting in orthostatic tachycardia, coldness of the extremities, episodes of sweating and profound pallor, sluggish pupils, bowel changes with possible hypothalamic injury.
          5. Diffuse and variable involvement of the CNS leading to ataxia, weakness and sensory changes in a limb, nerve root or peripheral nerve.
          6. Muscular pain, tenderness and myalgia.
          7. Recurrence in some patients over the several years that he followed them.




          Acheson (1959)


          Acheson's 1959 paper was based on research at the Royal Free Hospital into the 1955 outbreak there. An excerpt is reproduced below. It was a medical paper, and hence contains much technical terminology that I have tried to translate in parentheses [...].

           

            After an acute or subacute onset with headache, symptoms of gastro-intestinal or upper respiratory upset, muscular pains and low or absent fever, an unusual type of paresis [slight or partial paralysis] develops which is rarely associated with the classic signs of lower motor neurone or pyramidal tract involvement [the pyramidal tracts are four columns of motor fibers of which two run on each side of the spinal cord].

            This is often accompanied by paraesthesiae [a sensation of pricking, tingling, or creeping on the skin], sometimes by sensory loss, and occasionally by painful muscular spasms, myoclonus [irregular involuntary contraction of a muscle] or other types of involuntary movement. As the paresis recovers a curious jerky muscular contraction on volition has been noted in some instances. Involvement of the cranial nerves and the bladder may occur [the cranial nerves are the 12 paired nerves that arise from the lower surface of the brain with one of each pair on each side and pass through openings in the skull to the periphery of the body].

            Recovery has usually been completed within three months. In a proportion of cases, a well defined state of chronic ill health has developed, characterised by fluctuating myalgia and paresis, partial remission and exacerbation, and depression with emotional lability [instability] and lack of concentration.





          Ramsay's Definition

          (formalised 1988)


          In 1955, after an epidemic outbreak at the Royal Free Hospital in London, Dr Melvin Ramsay of the hospital's Infectious Diseases department coined the term 'Benign Myalgic Encephalomyelitis' for this illness. He later dropped the 'Benign' bit - for obvious reasons.

          More recently, some who have continued to research ME have preferred the name Myalgic Encephalopathy, since the -myelitis ending of the original name implies inflammation of myelin tissue by an infective agent, and it is not clear that this accurately represents the disease process in chronic or endemic cases. On the other hand, Encephalopathy can be demonstrated by autopsy, SPECT, QEEG, and PET scans and sometimes MRI.


            ME is an endemic disease which is subject to periodic epidemics.

            Onset

            Onset may be sudden and without apparent cause, for example a sudden attack of acute vertigo. There is usually a history of infection of the upper respiratory tract or, occasionally, the gastrointestinal tract. All cases have low grade pyrexia (up to 38 deg C) usually subsiding within a week.

            Subsequently there is persistent and profound fatigue, accompanied by a medley of symptoms such as headache, giddiness and a number of muscle symptoms such as pain, cramp, twitching, tenderness and weakness (especially after excercise). Other symptoms include paraesthesia, frequency of micturition [urination], blurred vision and/or diplopia, hyperacusis (sometimes alternating with deafness or normal hearing), tinnitus, fainting attacks which may be the result of hypoglycaemia and a general sense of "feeling awful".

            The Established Syndrome

            Once the syndrome is fully established there are three groups of symptoms:

            1. Muscle Phenomena

              • Muscle fatiguability. Even after a minor degree of physical excercise, 3 or more days may elapse before full muscle power is restored. This feature is unique and is the "sheet anchor" of diagnosis. In moderate cases there may be normal muscle power in remission.
              • Muscle spasm and twitching. In severe cases there may be swollen and very tender bands of muscle including minute focii of exquisite tenderness in trapezii and gastrocnemii (the muscle groups most commonly involved).

               

            2. Circulatory Impairment

              • Cold extremities.
              • Hypersensitivity to climactic change.
              • Ashen grey facial pallor, 20 to 30 minutes before patient complains of being ill

               

            3. Cerebral Dysfunction

                Cardinal Features

                • Impairment of memory
                • Impairment of powers of concentration
                • Emotional lability

                Other Common Features

                • Using the wrong words
                • Alteration to sleep rhythm or vivid dreams
                • Frequency of micturition
                • Hyperacuisis
                • Episodic sweating
                • Orthostatic tachycardia

                 

            • Other Notable Features

              • Variability of both symptoms and clinical findings during the day
              • Tendency to become chronic. Estimate at least 25%




          Return to homepage